Judy Hartley went to high school in Riverburg. That year, the school had a campus heartthrob—brilliant, charming, effortlessly handsome. He’d been admitted early to a top university at just sixteen. To say he was the unattainable dream boy would’ve been an understatement.

Half the girls in school had crushed on him, but no one ever got close. He was simply out of reach.

But someone managed to dig up an old thread from Riverburg High’s tiny alumni forum—and ...