Samuel turned away, telling William, "She couldn't fake this. Maybe I hurt her too deeply before." Especially during her miscarriage. Although he still hadn't discovered whose baby it was or who kidnapped her causing the miscarriage, he knew losing a baby was extremely traumatic for any woman. During her darkest moments, not only did he fail to care for her properly, but he also treated her poorly. Or perhaps she chose to forget him because of how much he and Chloe had hurt ...