Owen didn’t just bring Emma today—he also brought along her two sisters. At The Golden Chalice, they ran into a few of his old buddies and friends, turning the evening into a lively gathering with drinks flowing freely.

Perhaps they’d had too much to drink, or maybe it was something else, but Emma’s two sisters bumped into the new owner of The Golden Chalice in the hallway. Without knowing who he was, they boldly struck up a conversation, which inevitably led to ...