Vincent’s POV:

I held Gabby tightly in my arms, listening to her sobs, and it felt like my heart was being torn apart.

The truth is… I hadn’t told her everything about Toby.

Before Gabby lost her memory—right before she fell into the ocean—she had broken down completely. I remember her screaming through tears that someone had pushed Toby into the sea… and that he was gone.

I’ll never forget the way she cried that day. It tore ...