Katelyn appeared genuinely surprised by the reveal, so I could only imagine Andrew kept the inquiry from his daughter. He flinched before nodding slowly, clearly upset and shaken by everything falling apart around him.

"After the thefts," he said, "I started to wonder. I asked her a few things and Thea grew angry with me. Told me we'd agreed to stay out of each other's pasts. She was right, but I couldn't let it go. So I hired a detective to look into her." His misery ...