Jenn

Our days and nights are filled with one another. From hiking to the interior of the island and swimming in the fresh water of a waterfall to lying on the beach, we enjoy paradise. Throughout it all, we play with Paul’s fantasies. One by one, he reminds me how much better this kind of relationship can be with someone you trust completely.

It’s finally after six-plus days on the island that I summon the courage to open up to my husband, not sexually—I’ve ...