So there are a total of eight of us, but only seven shares. We get two of them. There are twelve items, and I argue that we should get four of the twelve. Orion agrees, making me more convinced that I screwed up the deal on the first floor.

Unfortunately, he also insists that we pick last each time around. So everyone else picks one item before each of us. The other four items will go three to them and one to us. So we pick sixth, seventh, eighth, and last.

Not surprisingly, we ...