Eileen and I walk hand in hand through the mostly quiet park, making our way along the water’s edge as the stars continue to shine down on us. The rippling water reflects her hair, giving her a shimmering glow under the moonlight. I gaze over at her, only to find her staring straight back at me. The blush on my cheeks intensifies, and she squeezes my hand fondly.

“You mind if I ask you something?” I inquire, turning my eyes down to the pavement in front of ...