Elena's POV

“Okay, but he literally didn’t look away from you while Sara was talking.”

"He didn’t do that," I said, reaching for my glass.

"He absolutely did,” Claire said, leaning forward with both elbows on the table, eyes wide. "I was right there, Elena. I saw the whole thing.”

Jenna laughed, stirring her drink slowly with her straw.

"Yeah, we were all watching,” she said, like it was obvious.

"You're both exaggerating," I said.

"We're observant." Jenna corrected, ...