Claire

When we get back to Andy's, we try to sneak in through the front door but are caught by Penny and Lucas, who are in the living room, watching a movie. I stand in front of Andy to shield his erection, and he wraps an arm around my waist.

"Hey, you two." Penny greets us, jumping up from the couch. "We weren't waiting up please don't think that."

"It kinda looks like you were, though." Andy chuckles, resting his head on my shoulder. His warm breath tickles my neck, ...