When Penn saw Brooke and Paige watching Jeeves, he knew he’d have to come up with a good story. They were entertained by Jeeves’ presence, and his having butler wouldn’t jibe with what they already knew about him.

“Have I caused problems with your neighbor?” Jeeves asked once he was inside.

“Not your fault, Jeeves. I should have come myself for this clothing. The woman who answered the door is the woman I’m protecting.”

He’d confided in Jeeves knowing the ...